How to Choose the Best Candy for Your Easter Egg Hunt

Spring has sprung, and you know what that means - Easter egg hunts, baskets, and the unmistakable sound of candy rattling around inside plastic eggs. Whether you’re planning a big neighborhood hunt or keeping things cozy with a family gathering, choosing the right candy can turn a good egg hunt into a legendary one. A little planning goes a long way when it comes to stuffing eggs, and the right mix of candy makes every “found one!” moment even sweeter.

Choose the Right Size Egg Hunt Candy

When you’re filling dozens (or let’s be honest, hundreds) of plastic eggs, size really does matter - at least for eggs. The best Easter egg hunt candy fits snugly inside without cracking the shell or popping the egg open.

Bite-sized candy keeps eggs balanced and easy to close, while individually wrapped pieces help keep things clean and colorful.

Bright wrappers don’t just look festive, they also make eggs easier to spot once the hunt is underway. A perfect example is the Hershey’s 70-piece Easter Egg Hunt Candy Assortment, a total crowd-pleaser packed with mini favorites like Reese’s eggs, Kit Kat bites, and more. Everything in the mix is egg-ready and guaranteed to put a smile on every face when baskets are dumped out at the end.

Adding a little theme magic can take an egg hunt from fun to totally unforgettable. Kids - and plenty of adults - love character candy, and themed eggs bring excitement before the hunt even begins.

Disney Egg Hunt Candy is a great way to sprinkle in some pixie dust, with pre-filled plastic eggs featuring favorite Disney characters.

If you want to crank up the cartoon energy, Nickelodeon Egg Hunt Candy delivers action-packed fun with familiar faces tucked inside ready-to-hide eggs. These themed options feel like a mini treasure hunt within the hunt, and they always seem to be the eggs kids remember most.

Variety is Key for Egg Hunt Candy

Variety is another big win when it comes to egg hunt candy. Some kids are all about chewy gummies, others won’t touch anything that isn’t chocolate, and mixing it up keeps every egg exciting. Assorted bags like the Hershey’s mix pull everything together so no two eggs feel exactly the same. 

Of course, not every egg has to be packed with sugar. If you have younger kids with candy limits or just want to add a few laughs, slipping in small surprises like stickers, small toys, or even “golden ticket” eggs for bonus prizes can be a fun touch. Candy may be the star of the show, but a few non-candy surprises make the hunt more inclusive and keep things creative without stealing the spotlight.

Here's one important tip to make your Easter egg hunt successful, and we can't stree how important this one is!  Ordering ahead is always smart because Easter candy goes fast!